I can't remember everyone's opinion on everything, but FO said that Liontamer liked this movie. I might be able to see why a comics fan would. I watched a feature on the comics on the 2nd DVD, and it seems the movie is faithful to the comics. Probably the most well-known line from the movie:

Quote:
Bullseye: You're good, baby, I'll give you that... but me? I'm magic.


was shown to have come from the comics.

Elektra's fate not only is the same as in the comics, but the way it unfolds even looks the same.