Terms of Service have been updated 06/07/08.
All new members must read and accept before posting.
| Author | Comment | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Kitsunexus |
Why do you guys hate anime? |
Lead | |||
|
Posts: 106 (05/20/08 3:24 PM) Banned User |
Seriously.
|
||||
TWEETER911 |
|||||
|
What?
"I flew into the wild and fire. I danced and died a thousand times."
|
|||||
Stepchan |
|||||
|
I know I like it.
But, I also know it's not for everyone.
I'm Catsuri, meow!
|
|||||
Stepchan |
|||||
|
Sorry for the double post...
I'm Catsuri, meow!
Last Edited By: Stepchan
05/20/08 4:51 PM.
Edited 1 times.
|
|||||
Forum Jackass |
|||||
|
I don't know if that's in response to Troy's post in the other topic, but he didn't actually say he hated anime. He just doesn't like
hentai. I'm pretty sure he's said he's liked other anime in the past.
In my case, it's just a medium like anything else. There is some good, some great, and a lot of bad.
Oh my God, they found Tom.
|
|||||
CLOUDBOND007 |
|||||
|
I was under the impression that a lot of people here liked at least some anime. They just don't have such an obsessive love for it that they'll enjoy
any anime movie no matter it's flaws.
|
|||||
Flying Omelette |
|||||
|
Also, there's a difference between saying "I hate all anime" and "I just don't see where all anime is superior to all other forms of
animation". Cartoon Planet (aka the "other" show with Space Ghost) was one of the funniest cartoons I remember seeing in the past 10 years, but
I'm not going to pretend it was animated as well as The Lion King.
|
|||||
da dick |
|||||
|
psssttt.... tweeter LOVES anime and pantsu upskirt action!!! you 2 should go on a date. and cloudbondu can be chaperon(sp?
|
|||||
CLOUDBOND007 |
|||||
|
Nah, we'd probably all end up dead.
|
|||||
MaskedSheik |
|||||
|
Yeah, I like some animé, but I don't believe it's a superior art form brought to earth by the Olympic deities or something. I know there are
gaming message boards and hangouts whose members feel that way......and because of this, it's become sort of an expectation for gamers to also be fervent
fans of animé. You're probably jumping from that expectation when you ask us why we "hate" animé. We don't. We're just sober about it.
|
|||||
Flying Omelette |
|||||
Flying Omelette wrote: Gee, I kind of forgot my connecting thought sentence there. What I basically meant is to say is that it's also possible to like something despite being
aware of its flaws.
|
|||||
Akhiloth |
|||||
|
What? Who said s/he doesn't like anime?
|
|||||
IcePhoenix721 |
|||||
|
I don't hate anime myself. Some of it, like the others have already said, is great and others are terrible. ex. Cowboy Bebop in my opinion is awesome and
Shuffle! Memories was indescribably bad. Of course somebody will probably disagree, really it is just a matter of personal tastes.
To the world you may be one person, but to one person you may be the
world.
Last Edited By: IcePhoenix721
05/22/08 3:11 AM.
Edited 1 times.
|
|||||
da dick |
|||||
|
shuffle the manga sucks as masturbating material. that's all i can say.
cowboy bebop is like jerry bruckhiemer(sp?) productions, entertaining enough but not exactly a work of art. some people seem to think it's as good as futurama.
|
|||||
ACC KAIN |
|||||
|
I'm named after an anime character, but my experience with it in general is limited to a few movies we rented and a few shows that have been aired on
network TV and cartoon network. I like some of what I've seen, but I'm not a diehard fan who knows a lot about obscure stuff.
"No one can withstand
the power of KAIN"
|
|||||
da dick |
|||||
|
your name is guyver!?!?
|
|||||
CRAWLand1000 |
|||||
|
I do think it's bad that anime has such a clearly defined visual style (it is completely ridiculous how similar some animes look to each other, and how
generic the character design is), and that kids today grow up trying to imitate it. What happened to originality and self expression?
"Without a foothold in the past, we cannot walk towards the future." -Vagrant Story |
|||||
ErniePants |
|||||
|
I don't hate it but I don't watch it as much as I used to. Too expensive to keep buying, rental places have limited selections, and most of what's
shown on TV is either crap or stuff I've already seen.
The Omni-Wonder
of the Universe has spoken
~cackle ~cackle |
|||||
CRAWLand1000 |
|||||
Too expensive to keep buyingWhy does every hobby have to fuel the consumer culture? If you want to be a videogamer, you always have to buy new systems, rare games, import games, the latest games... I even get annoyed when I see people going on and on about how much music gear they have. I mean, isn't the point of playing music so that you can finally create something yourself? And you're just using it as an opportunity to buy more crap! I wouldn't be surprised if a big reason a lot of people play golf is because its consumer nature keeps out the riff raff. "Without a foothold in the past, we cannot walk towards the future." -Vagrant Story |
|||||
Kitsunexus |
|||||
|
Posts: 106 (05/30/08 4:37 PM) Banned User |
Last Edited By: Flying Omelette
05/31/08 10:05 AM.
Edited 1 times.
|
||||
da dick |
|||||
|
oh fun. kid nexus gonna gonna turn this place into a hentai magnet.
|
|||||
ErniePants |
|||||
|
The Omni-Wonder
of the Universe has spoken
~cackle ~cackle |
|||||
Crawl and 1OOO |
|||||
|
Another thing about anime is that it's very much a teenager thing.
I think a reason for that is that when a person is a teenager is around the time they try to figure out their own identity. And to make things really binary, you're either like other people, in which case you probably don't need to do much soul searching to figure out your identity, or you're not like other people. And if you're not like other people, that means that you can't like things other people like, so you have to find something new (at least to you). And anime had a built-in "exotic" factor. I'm not sure what that'll be like in a generation, since Americans are now getting exposed to anime earlier. FO was telling me today how she hates Azumanga Daioh and would instantly reject any SAB submissions that involve it. She said that almost every picture she's seen on the internet from it show some characters doing something goofy, and then the same two characters looking at them stone-faced. |
|||||
da dick |
|||||
|
by your argument, crawl... all yellow people who like anime could well be strict conformist-type adults which can't dig "exotic" western fare
like south park or futurama. i'm not sure i can twist statistical results to proof that.
as for Azumanga Daioh. it is a chick flick or a chick flick made for male perverts depending on who you ask. i like to categorise shit like that with "easy listening" music and babytalk. i don't see how it's any worse than "norby" or whatever you call that stop-animation gnome thing. |
|||||
Crawl and 1OOO |
|||||
|
No, not at all. I don't have an a priori argument. People who like anime a lot that I've met tend to be
teenagers, or close to it. That's just a fact.
I doubt American culture seems as exotic to Asians as Asian culture seems to Americans, anyway. Actually, though, now that I've typed this, I have read some blogs from some Americans living in Japan who have described Japanese male teens doing their best to act like gangster rappers. |
|||||
Crawl and 1OOO |
|||||
|
Another thing that makes anime a teenager thing is that it can have things that could not be in a cartoon for little kids, like extreme violence or swearing.�
So, that makes teenagers think it's "adult" and not "kiddie".� But it's not really mature enough to be adult.�
Take this for example. It's like, kids can't have violence or swearing, so when you finally get the chance to get some, you go completely overboard.� A lot of times when kids get to do "adult" things for the first time, they overindulge.� So, you get things like binge drinking in college. |
|||||
Akhiloth |
|||||
|
Don't tell me that's not targeted to adults.
|
|||||
Crawl and 1OOO |
|||||
|
...he says just after I said it was for teens.
Adults might care that, say, the acting is horrible. Teens just want the violence and swearing. Kind of like with horror movies. Except that when I think back to the time that I heard the most people talk enthusiastically about the Nightmare on Elm Street or Friday the 13th movies, I wasn't a teen; I was in grade school.
Last Edited By: Flying Omelette
06/30/08 6:04 AM.
Edited 2 times.
|
|||||
Crawl and 1OOO |
|||||
|
...but thanks for affirming that teenagers judge the maturity of a show in the most superficial way.
Here's a scene with swearing that's intended for adults. |
|||||
TaroSH |
|||||
|
It's kind of like what Yahtzee says somewhere in his Manhunt review: Talking about beating a guy with a board with nails in it into a blood mess when you're a kid is a great way to make friends,
but talking about that stuff when you're an adult is a great way to lose them.
Last Edited By: TaroSH
06/30/08 10:57 AM.
Edited 1 times.
|
|||||
James FP |
|||||
|
I remember people at the Game Pond and other old ezboards arguing that Dragon Ball Z was meant for adults. Probably because of the violence, but even as
violent as it is, it's still very cartoony. Frieza gets cut in half, and then floats around a few minutes later. People get blown up, but go to a silly
upsidedown world with a goofy fat beetle-man and bumbling demons. It always struck me as something aimed so obviously at prepubescent males.
|
|||||